Note: If you’re just going to come in and engage with me in an uncivil manner with your dick behavior, you’ll be auto blocked.
One part that gets me is when they stated that they took art classes. Just, what is the point of taking art classes today? There have been artists whose stories I’ve read about and heard of, who spent years practicing their craft to get to where they are. The idea of taking an art class for an otherwise approachable hobby just always feels odd to me and always will. There are countless ways to improve one’s art and craft, not by AI though.
And then right after, they mention about practicing. So again - what’s the point of taking art classes?
I stopped reading about half way through, because my mind went “yeah yeah yeah…” since nothing this comic artist was saying anything new that I hadn’t heard of in regards to anti-AI.
Here’s my stance on AI Art and it’s going to rub people the wrong way but I don’t care. I was told by an artist friend whom I’ve known and has done pictures for me before. They started raising their prices a smidge for their commissions and this artist was and is on their way of being recognized as a good artist in their community (they’re furry). We got into a conversation about how I brought up that prices could be hard to achieve because of the economy and blah blah.
They told me in response that ‘Art is a luxury’. And you know what? It kinda is. It is a luxury and sets a baseline as to what one can and can’t afford. If someone is frustrated enough that they can’t afford some $300 commission piece (yes those people do exist), they’re going to go to AI because they know they can do it at home. Now it doesn’t excuse the fact that they could’ve just picked up art as a hobby and actually practice, there is that argument. However, not everyone is an artist and not everyone is going to practice it.
And if someone isn’t going to practice art and isn’t able to afford high prices asked of the artists who have open commissions - what do you honestly expect them to do?
As far as things regarding like studios function and how this all relates to them, that’s a whole can of worms of its own. How many times have we heard animation studios or other studios get shut down because the funding dried up? “Oh we planned 2 seasons in advance - oh wait - we can only do one season now” and then that’s a wrap of that series.
I don’t know where I want to go with that and this has been lengthy anyways so I’ll just summarize it as this. I don’t have a big problem with AI Art because Art and Creativity in of itself, is a luxury. It’s an expensive luxury at that, that has its limits. That is why people have turned to AI in droves. I don’t agree with a lot of the reasons behind what people do with AI Art and proclaiming themselves as ‘artists’ when they’re not (I prefer to call them envisonists because you are still inputting and projecting the imaginations of your mind into an input that can visualize it for you).
The point is the same as taking classes for any other skill, from baseball to carpentry: you have to learn technique before you can engrain the skill through practice. Some people can pick it up on their own if they’re motivated enough, by studying other people’s art, watching artists working, reading books, etc., but it’s more difficult and time-consuming without an instructor’s feedback. Sometimes they even figure it out wrong, and develop a very difficult and time-consuming method of doing something when a much simpler one exists.
So it’s optimal to both have the classes and do extensive practice outside of them. One is not a substitute for the other.
I was going to read this but stopped halfway through because my mind went “yeah that yeah another person who never bothered trying to draw having a hot take that’s just sucking off a tech bro”
Note: If you’re just going to come in and engage with me in an uncivil manner with your dick behavior, you’ll be auto blocked.
One part that gets me is when they stated that they took art classes. Just, what is the point of taking art classes today? There have been artists whose stories I’ve read about and heard of, who spent years practicing their craft to get to where they are. The idea of taking an art class for an otherwise approachable hobby just always feels odd to me and always will. There are countless ways to improve one’s art and craft, not by AI though.
And then right after, they mention about practicing. So again - what’s the point of taking art classes?
I stopped reading about half way through, because my mind went “yeah yeah yeah…” since nothing this comic artist was saying anything new that I hadn’t heard of in regards to anti-AI.
Here’s my stance on AI Art and it’s going to rub people the wrong way but I don’t care. I was told by an artist friend whom I’ve known and has done pictures for me before. They started raising their prices a smidge for their commissions and this artist was and is on their way of being recognized as a good artist in their community (they’re furry). We got into a conversation about how I brought up that prices could be hard to achieve because of the economy and blah blah.
They told me in response that ‘Art is a luxury’. And you know what? It kinda is. It is a luxury and sets a baseline as to what one can and can’t afford. If someone is frustrated enough that they can’t afford some $300 commission piece (yes those people do exist), they’re going to go to AI because they know they can do it at home. Now it doesn’t excuse the fact that they could’ve just picked up art as a hobby and actually practice, there is that argument. However, not everyone is an artist and not everyone is going to practice it.
And if someone isn’t going to practice art and isn’t able to afford high prices asked of the artists who have open commissions - what do you honestly expect them to do?
As far as things regarding like studios function and how this all relates to them, that’s a whole can of worms of its own. How many times have we heard animation studios or other studios get shut down because the funding dried up? “Oh we planned 2 seasons in advance - oh wait - we can only do one season now” and then that’s a wrap of that series.
I don’t know where I want to go with that and this has been lengthy anyways so I’ll just summarize it as this. I don’t have a big problem with AI Art because Art and Creativity in of itself, is a luxury. It’s an expensive luxury at that, that has its limits. That is why people have turned to AI in droves. I don’t agree with a lot of the reasons behind what people do with AI Art and proclaiming themselves as ‘artists’ when they’re not (I prefer to call them envisonists because you are still inputting and projecting the imaginations of your mind into an input that can visualize it for you).
The point is the same as taking classes for any other skill, from baseball to carpentry: you have to learn technique before you can engrain the skill through practice. Some people can pick it up on their own if they’re motivated enough, by studying other people’s art, watching artists working, reading books, etc., but it’s more difficult and time-consuming without an instructor’s feedback. Sometimes they even figure it out wrong, and develop a very difficult and time-consuming method of doing something when a much simpler one exists.
So it’s optimal to both have the classes and do extensive practice outside of them. One is not a substitute for the other.
I was going to read this but stopped halfway through because my mind went “yeah that yeah another person who never bothered trying to draw having a hot take that’s just sucking off a tech bro”