following this URL https://feddit.nl/post/32689004. it looks like the software taken down the source and the codeberg is gone
Access to macOS and Windows releases are currently restricted to sponsors, a 5 USD monthly sponsorship is required.
What the fuck?
Fuck that, isn’t this just a maintained fork of clementine??
And I tried this player, it’s nothing special
I could understand a permanent nag button like nanazip, but $60/year where most of the hard job (libraries, decoders, base ui) was done by someone else for free?
I’m blacklisting this shit even if I’m a Linux user
What is wrong with this policy? Strawberry is GPL, this sounds like the dev is committed enough to FOSS to not care too much about issues that come up on proprietary operating systems. This is very obviously not going to bring in a lot of money, how many people do you picture using windows or mac who think strawberry is so much better than other options that it’s worth paying for? They’re not advertising this in any way, there’s no plot to trick poor souls into paying.
It strikes me as an easy and effective way to dismiss without argument bugfix requests on operating systems the developer doesn’t care to touch. It’s saying we don’t want to neglect any users on other platforms that sincerely care about our project, but otherwise we just want to prioritze FOSS, so let’s write off essentially all proprietary OS users while providing an avenue in case someone actually does care about our project that much.
I wouldn’t even look at it or think of it on windows.
what do you think the best local music/mp3 player?
Big fan of MusicBee, been using it for years.
Yes, it’s really good! I still run it with proton, because I couldn’t find a good alternative on Linux. banshee is unmaintained (it was my favorite for a long time) and all others have their shortcomings in some way or another.
What’s wrong with Clementine? I have yet to find a better desktop music player. Radios, podcasts, library, playlists, what’s missing?
My understanding is that Clementine is no longer maintained.
Yeah, that is more or less true. Although the github page is a newer version than the web page says it is.
It builds and works great though.
Looks like garbage, can’t support multiple genre tags. Might as well be VLC as far as music management.
God I miss MusicBee.
Foobar2k is amazing and still has a very active community making extensions and plugins.
Looks like garbage? Wtf? Looks great and is easy to use I am so confused by this comment.
I don’t use genres so I guess that is a valid complaint if you use them.
As far as music management, other than genre, what is missing?
I have it connected to over 4tb of my music and its fast, searches work on many levels, and I have never seen a player better.
It looks like Windows Vista. Not a fan.
Multiple genre tags are a big part of how I search around my collection. This feature built into ID3 over 25 years ago. Absolute lunacy that I can only find three players anywhere that support it (MusicBee, Quod Libet, Foobar and derivatives). Otherwise, MB’s layout just felt more clean, intuitive, and user-friendly.
Clementine wouldn’t recognize my phone, either, so reading/syncing was also out. Basically none of the reasons I wanted it worked and I hated the way it looked. But apparently all most people ask of music players is “plays music.mp3 when I navigate to the folder and double click on the icon.” In which case any of them do that, so Clementine isn’t anything special.
Apologies for the tone. I’m pretty bitter about the state of music players on Linux.
Literally just use Winamp. You’re on windows, it’s windows amp. Winamp.
Yeah but that poor llama
Not the person you responded to, but on Linux, i think quod libet is the best for me. On Windows, (still) foobar2000.
I tried quod libet. the design is more like GTK than qt that strawberry/clementine and it is much more retro like and stable. So far so good
Awesome, glad you like it so far. Also take a look at the plugins from the main menu. it comes with a bunch and most are disabled by default. It is also, if you are so technically inclined, relatively easy to write new plugins in Python.
VLC.
Else it’s Jellyfin Web/Jellyfin Media Player on PC or for smartphone it’s Symfonium and FinampTempo on android is open source and IMO nicer than Symfonium
Same/Similar featureset?
If yes, can you drop a link? :)I’m not the one you’re asking, but it seems to be this repo on Github and I read that it works because Jellyfin does/can(?) expose a Subsonic API.
I believe Jellyfin has a subsonic plugin in some un-/official repository.
But I’d rather stay first party to avoid too much dependency on various plugins preventing me from upgrading.
I’m running a navidrome instance as well that I connect to with tempo. They can share libraries (or at least I have, without any issues)
mpd
ncmpcpp plus mopidy and you’ve even got Spotify
Well I prefer termusic, but ncmpcpp is good too. Never heard about mopidy tho.
mpd + M.A.L.P. = <3
Tauon.
Failing that mod+cantata (although I think this is not really maintained anymore).
cmus the cli C music player.
On Android: Musicolet or Oto music
I am the author of Strawberry Music Player and I would like you to remove it from the winget package manager.
The source code repository and releases from https://codeberg.org/WetOtter44/StrawberryMusicPlayer that you use as source for these packages are not official. It is an unofficial clone of the official source code repository for Strawberry Music Player (https://github.com/strawberrymusicplayer/strawberry), with misleading releases tagged to the wrong commits. If this was a valid fork, it should be renamed to not misrepresent our community project, and any links should not point to our bug tracker and support forum. The person who uploaded these were given the binary installations files from me for testing purposes, he has since proven willing to harm the project, I won’t share his real name, but as you can see by the profile on codeberg he is anonymous for these reasons. He may upload releases containing malicious executables. The official Windows releases for Strawberry Music Player are given to users on request, I do not want it included in a package manager where users can install Strawberry Music Player without any information on how to fund the project.First part valid, but last sentence lol. Open source go brrrr.
Bit strange, the Strawberry app itself already mentions how to donate in the Help/About Strawberry window. Maybe the dev could distribute the Windows/MacOS binaries and simply code in a massive donation pop-up when the OS detected <> Linux.
@brickfrog @far_university1990 The dev saying it’s about “information on how to fund the project” is being… misleading. Windows binaries from the project are paywalled, so alternate builds being distributed via Winget presents a pretty clear threat to that funding by being free and more convenient.* They’re well within their right to not distribute their own builds for free, but the misleading way it’s framed here is not endearing… especially given this is a fork of another piece of FOSS software that will happily provide you Windows builds.
* As an aside, it really is so much better to have stuff distributed by a package manager. Who the hell wants to download an installer from Patreon for every new release, honestly. Some devs drive me crazy with their insistence on asinine distribution channels.
Your mention not ping me. Sure this work?
But you could patch it out ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
*should
Not that I could. But if, I would ;)
You can complain to the dev on their official forum https://forum.strawberrymusicplayer.org/category/2/general-discussion. He is quite active there
I was wondering when that repo showed up and all of a sudden there were 50k downloads of the windows version if this might happen.
The coderberg fork was linked directly to the main strawberry page where the source code is and it’s pretty obvious the downloads were just the same as any subscriber executables.
I highly doubt the story that the person behind the fork was given binaries for testing. My guess is it was just a subscriber sharing their downloaded executables.
The whole malware argument the creator made is fear mongering.
Its odd he charges $7/month for subscribers on Patreon but its only $5 if you pay via Kofi.
Well i’ve setup a fork and modified the workflow file to build windows and macos: https://github.com/PorcoDio00033/strawberry/actions/runs/17040509548
I’ve not tested those binaries because i dont use that player, but they should work because entire workflow ran without errors.
The original repo already builds both windows + macos binaries, but it pushes them to a private server, not publically in actions/releases.
Paywalling binaries doesnt make sense lol
Cloned the repo and ran the actions. Works like a charm. Setup a Kofi I’d much rather give you $5
Note: github will not let you build arm64 as a private repo
Submit to winget under different name ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Patreon takes a 20% cut of your income right off the bat. This is with the 8% platform fee option, and when you stack it on top of the payment processing fees, that’s what it comes out to be.
kofi is a bit lower but I don’t know the details there.
But it makes sense to pass those fees on to the subscribers.
Yeah that’s kind of what I figured but not sure why a customer would just choose the more expensive option.
It’s easier for me to us Patreon, because I’m already supporting a few other people/organizations there.
I’ve never used Ko-fi for a subscription.
Fair enough. I’m cheap so I’d quibble over the extra $2/month 😂
Post title misleading, Strawberry project still up and running at https://github.com/strawberrymusicplayer/strawberry , coincidentally I had just installed it on Debian 13. Then saw this post saying Strawberry was taken down except that it wasn’t.
Like the other comment says this is just about unofficial binaries that were floating around. That said it’s kind of a bummer that Windows/Mac users can’t download pre-compiled binaries from their github page. Maybe someone can create a script that does the downloading/compiling for those OSes similar to how some ffmpeg scripts do it e.g. https://github.com/UBTL/ffmpeg-windows-build
Yes, I updated the title. But, I do not think the author happy with the fork that promote automated compiling because as it said from the takedown post it disrupt the subscription fees
https://github.com/strawberrymusicplayer/strawberry this not it?
Edit:
The program is free software, released under GPL. If you like this program and can make use of it, consider sponsoring or donating to help fund the project.
Illegal not provide source.
the problem is the original Windows and macOSX is version are paywalled. The codeberg version are the compiled versions and the free alternatives
You can still compile it from source.
convenience especially with winget is still the best and not everyone is the developer
Submit build script to winget build directly from their repo?
Winget just downloads an installer from the source.
Microsoft doesn’t provide build time or hosting space (except if you’re using GitHub)
Repo only contains URL to download and hash for check
I mean winget contain script that download from official repo then compile on user pc. Like aur pkgbuild.
I tried once to compile sm64 on windows and I took over 1 hour and dozens of gigabyte to download and install all the prerequisites, plus visual studio clutters the start menu with lots of “useless” shit, normal people gonna get pissed
I do not think the author is happy with this because as it said from the takedown post. it disrupts the subscription money.
Then should not release source code under copyleft license.
On Windows? Where you need to install visual studio and 10 gb of libraries?
Have compiled source and checked for paywall?
I feel like having stroke reading that title
